Tessera
Trilogy Blog
Post 160
Process – Progress as
determined by page count, word count and percent stands as follows: total pages
up to 173; total word countdown up to 93.4 K, and percent is 47.9 percent. I
continue to work several review segments simultaneously to maintain momentum.
BAM 17 August 2015 critique comments
BAM member –
1.
Minor editorial changes –
agree
2.
Didn’t follow use of “lunch” “launch” - subtle humor
3.
Reads well – thanks
4.
Suggested remove “”and I’m
in the middle of it.” – disagree,
the MD’s insight
5.
“It was” doesn’t fit –
agree, working
6.
Thought water truck
destroyed – no, only hit with fragments
BAM member –
1.
Well written, continues to
get better – thanks
2.
Minor editorial changes –
agree, working
3.
Didn’t follow use of
“lunch” “launch” - subtle humor
4.
Felt “sonofabitch” overused
– agree, working
5.
Suggested use different
word for “frazzled” – agree, working
6.
Reads very well and keeps
you going; well done – thanks
7.
Good ending, funny - thanks
BAM member –
1.
Suggested no use “It was.”
– agree, working
2.
Minor editorial changes –
agree, working
3.
Clear and fast moving –
thanks
4.
Lots of repetitive names,
Ben Bedoo – disagree;
father (MG), son (Cpt) – foreshadowing
BAM member –
1.
Liked the action – thanks
2.
Kept wanting to read more –
thanks
3.
Enjoyed the humor sprinkled
in - thanks
4.
Good description, verbs
used – thanks
5.
Questioned use of “lunch”
“launch” - subtle humor
6.
Questioned use of
“sonofabitch”, “shit” – disagree;
they’d just been bombed
BAM member –
1.
Liked the action - thanks
2.
Good descriptions – thanks
3.
Liked the inklings/hints
about water truck – thanks
4.
Enjoyed last line – “Duck!”
– thanks
5.
Good dialogue between Anh
and Tooley – thanks
6.
“It was” doesn’t fit –
agree, working
7.
Good use of humor – thanks
8.
Enjoyed having kids in
description - thanks
BAM member –
1.
Liked the action - thanks
2.
Anh and Tooley’s dialogue
artificial - working
3.
Remove “It was.” – agree,
working
4.
Is Tooley the POV – at
points
5.
Suggested rearranging
search for locators and weapons – agree, working
BAM member –
1.
Very interesting
action - thanks
2.
Unique dialogue – thanks
3.
Good cut, back and forth in
scenes – thanks
4.
Was able to follow without
getting lost – thanks
5.
Interesting development -
thanks
BAM member –
1.
Enjoyed the humor,
especially “Duck!” - thanks
2.
“Ghoutra” not understood –
traditional male Saudi head gear
3.
Reads well, I understood
and followed – thanks
BAM member -
1.
Liked the action and comedy
- thanks
2.
Minor editorial changes –
agree, and disagree
BAM member –
1.
Makes you hang on - thanks
2.
No written comments
No comments:
Post a Comment