Tessera
Trilogy Blog
Post 235
The working draft of The Next
One now stands at 129 pages reviewed.
*********************************************
BAM 04 September 2017 critique
comments
A far more satisfying set of comments
and suggestions were provided than recent critiques. The night was encouraging.
Progress!?
There are only three draft segments left for review before a full review of the
entire novel starts.
BAM member –
1.
Great pacing and
tension, detail - thanks
2.
Pace the growing
frustration of not knowing where terrorist vehicles are by creating differing
incident reports – agree, working
3.
Describe how they’re
tracking terrorist vehicles, and how initially unaware where vans were – agree,
working
4.
Show readers how
they know which vehicles they are chasing – agree, working
5.
Segment sounded
credible, ratcheted up tension very well – thanks
6.
Mechanisms of
confusion as to van locations well done – thanks
7.
Eliminate
duplicate use of ATF Agent Bellowes’ name – agree, working
8.
Minor editorial
suggestions – agree, working
9.
Clarify what “thing”
is going according to FBI team plan – agree, working
BAM member –
1.
Confused as to
how the team was able to track the vans – working
2.
Correct POV issue
of knowing how four other vans left parking lot – agree, working
3.
Missed where one
of terrorists was working with FBI team; reader is unaware – agree, will insert
additional hints. Am trying to maintain degree of mystery about Adnan.
4.
Suggested making
Padrino a mailman, or package delivery man – disagree, signage on van would be different, but will
improve
5.
Reduce multiple
use of “sleep” – agree, working
6.
Clarify what is
meant by “a display” – agree, working (refers to another monitor)
7.
Paragraph on
introduction of additional, phony vans was good use of cinematic POV – thanks
8.
Explain why if
team is tracking vans they are arresting the terrorists – agree, need to
clarify that huge bombs involved and FBI/ATF don’t want local cops to intrude
BAM member –
1.
Exceptional, kept
up good momentum – thanks
2.
Improve
transitions to omniscient POV scenes – agree, working
3.
Tighten up the
van situation – agree, working
4.
Minor editorial
suggestions – agree, working
5.
Reduce multiple
use of “sleep” – agree, working
BAM member –
1.
Good pacing,
liked this segment – thanks
2.
Have Judy
actually curse, don’t say she does – agree, working
3.
Too many internal
thoughts – agree, working
4.
Liked “Are our
terrorists adrift?” – thanks
5.
Improve wording
of rear mirror view – agree, working
6.
Liked use of fake
plates – thanks
7.
Delete use of “Breath
in, breath out.” – agree, working
8.
Make greater
distinction between techniques of local cops vs. FBI – agree
9.
Indent start of
fourth paragraph – agree
10. Numerous editorial suggestions – agree, working
11. Reduce multiple use of “exit” – agree, working
12. Explain how the team knows of stolen license plates –
agree, working
13. Paragraph on other drivers and vans introducing
additional vans gave me chills - thanks
BAM member –
1.
Really enjoyed -
thanks
2.
Eliminate
duplicate use of ATF Agent Bellowes’ name – agree, working
No comments:
Post a Comment