Tessera
Trilogy Blog
Post 195
Progress as determined by page count, word count
and percent stands as follows: total page count went down to 181; total word
count inched down to 97.6 K, and percent increased to 98.2 percent.
RWG 11 June 2016 critique comments
RWG member –
1.
Urgency of war realistic – thanks
2.
Resonates with me as a reader – thanks
3.
The tone is exciting; political dialogue feels real – thanks
4.
Politicians lying to each other seems realistic, enjoyed it - thanks
RWG member (new member) –
1.
Pace too fast – disagree
2.
Narration jumps often without leadins – agree; working
3.
Use characters to describe feelings - agree
4.
Minor editorial comments – agreed with half
5.
Rodolofo too poetic in his words – agree; working
6.
Reword “mélange of prayers” – agree; working
RWG member -
1.
Show how Commander-in-Chief tensed – agree
2.
Describe age of kids sooner – agree
3.
Identify town – done in earlier segment
4.
Clarify APC – armored personnel carriers – agree; working
5.
Minor editorial changes – agree; working
RWG member –
1.
Questioned meanings of CRITIC
and BROKEN ARROW – described, defined earlier
2.
No written comments
RWG member –
1.
Suggested describing “ethnic
embellishments” – agree; working
2.
Change Peace to lower case –
agree
3.
Name Israeli family as participants – disagree; they’d be throwaway characters
4.
No written comments
RWG member –
1.
No written comments provided
2.
One of your best; your writing is improving – thanks
3.
Questioned whether “Kibbutzim” was a realistic Israeli family name –
working
4.
Action and plot clear; some language too flowery – agree; working
5.
POTUS wouldn’t speak that way (blunt) – disagree
6.
Couldn’t establish the story, flow - working
No comments:
Post a Comment