Tessera
Trilogy Blog post 123
Sales
of Sooley Base have picked up!!! Yea!!!
A segment of Kashan Kashmeeri was
reviewed/critiqued at a Monday Books-A-million meeting.
Reviewer comments:
After revising the segment it was taken
to the BAM meeting. The segment was read and critiqued at the end of the
meeting.
BAM members
provided written critiques of the segment as follows:
BAM member
1.
Well
written, good dialogue – agree
2.
Explain
how Wednesday relates to Muslim Friday – agree; in process
- Incorporate reference to when character
served on ships – agree;
in process
4.
Minor
editorial changes – agree
5.
Suggested
word changes – agree
6.
Show
me around …” not believable, incorporate more to and fro – agree; in process
BAM member
1.
Unconvincing
use of female dialogue (not what they’d say)
2.
Explain
how Wednesday relates to Muslim Friday – agree; in process
3.
Minor
editorial changes – agree
BAM member
1.
Was
uncertain of gender of character – disagree; clear from previous segments and text
2.
Uncertain
of use of POV – agree; in process
3.
Unclear
of setting - disagree;
clear from previous text
4.
Characters
posing questions was distracting – agree; in process
5.
Change
question to statement punctuation wise – agree; in process
6.
Change
sequence of sentences – agree; in process
BAM member
1.
No written comments
2.
Not
hard to follow, interesting
No comments:
Post a Comment